Is any mistake strong enough to cancel a contract according to Ethiopian Law?
In the sphere of legal agreements, understanding the implications of mistake in contracts is crucial. If you’re wondering whether a mistake in a contract can be significant enough to cancel it according to Ethiopian law, this blog post is here to guide you through the complexities.
The Inevitability of Mistake
Mistakes are a natural part of everyday life and, unsurprisingly, they can also occur when drafting contracts. These mistakes can range from minor errors, which can be easily corrected, to major ones that may have the potential to invalidate a contract. In this article, we will explore the distinction between minor and major mistake, and how The Ethiopian Civil Code addresses each.
Major Mistake: Decisive and Fundamental Errors
For a mistake to be considered major and capable of invalidating a contract, it must meet two cumulative requirements: decisiveness and fundamentality.
Decisive Mistake: This refers to a scenario where a party would not have entered into the contract had they known the truth. Essentially, it’s about the importance of the truth in the decision-making process.
Fundamental Mistake: This pertains to the core elements of the contract, such as the nature or object of the contract, or the identity or qualifications of the contracting parties.
Examples of Major Mistake
- Nature of the Contract: Imagine a situation where a party believes they are entering into a contract of sale, but the agreement is actually a lease contract. This misunderstanding about the nature of the contract can be a fundamental mistake.
- Object of the Contract: Consider a scenario where a party agrees to sell a Mercedes Benz but mistakenly believes it to be an old Volkswagen Beetle. Here, the misunderstanding about the object of the contract is substantial enough to be considered a fundamental mistake.
- Identity or Qualification of a Contracting Party: Suppose you enter into a contract with an accountant, not knowing they have a criminal history of embezzlement or document forgery. The mistake regarding the identity or qualification of the party can be crucial.
Minor Mistakes: Easily Correctable Errors
Minor mistakes, while they may cause inconvenience, do not have the power to invalidate a contract. Examples include:
- Motives: If someone rents a hall for a wedding and the wedding is subsequently canceled, this does not invalidate the rental contract. The agreed-upon payment must still be made.
- Arithmetic Errors: Calculation errors in the contract can be corrected once identified. For instance, if the parties agreed on the price of an item but made a calculation error when drafting the contract, this can be amended without invalidating the agreement.
Good Faith Requirement
A crucial aspect to consider is the invocation of mistake in good faith. Ethiopian law mandates that mistake must be claimed in good faith to invalidate a contract. If a party invokes a mistake to unjustly avoid the effects of a contract, they are liable to repair any damage resulting from the invalidation. However, this does not apply if the other party was aware or should have been aware of the mistake, such as a gold expert knowingly buying fake gold.
Understanding the implications of mistake in contracts is vital for anyone involved in legal agreements. Major mistakes that are both decisive and fundamental can potentially invalidate a contract under Ethiopian law. Conversely, minor mistakes, such as errors in motives or arithmetic, do not have the same effect. Always remember the importance of good faith in invoking mistake to ensure the fair application of the law.
If you have any question or comment don’t hesitate to contact us.
